When you’re setting up a trust or reviewing one you’ve already created, you may come across a provision known as the “5 by 5 rule.” This guideline helps determine how much a beneficiary can withdraw from a trust each year without creating unintended tax consequences.
Because the rule connects directly to estate and tax laws, even a small misunderstanding can affect long-term goals for preserving and distributing family assets.
Applying this correctly requires careful attention to how the trust is written and how it functions in real life. That’s why many people choose to speak with an Orlando estate planning lawyer to make sure their withdrawal provisions support their broader plan.
What Is the 5 by 5 Rule?
The 5 by 5 rule—also known as the 5 by 5 power—is a provision sometimes included in trusts to regulate a beneficiary’s right to withdraw funds. Under this rule, the beneficiary may withdraw the greater of $5,000 or 5% of the trust’s value each year.
The 5 by 5 rule plays an important role in maintaining the balance between a beneficiary’s access to trust funds and the long-term protection of the trust itself.
This rule also provides a tax-related safeguard. By keeping the beneficiary’s access within these boundaries, the rule aims to protect the trust’s long-term purpose while also minimizing potential estate and gift tax consequences.
To consult with an experienced estate planning lawyer today
(855) 780-9986
How the 5 by 5 Rule Works in Common Trust Structures
The effect of the 5 by 5 rule depends on the type of trust and the goals behind it. In irrevocable trusts, the rule is often used to give beneficiaries limited withdrawal rights without compromising the trust’s asset-protection or tax-planning purposes. Because the trust cannot be altered once created, these controlled withdrawal powers help maintain stability.
For family or living trusts, the rule supports measured distributions over time. It allows beneficiaries to access funds when needed while still preserving the trust’s value for future use, which is often central to a long-term estate plan.
Is the 5 by 5 Rule Automatic?
The 5 by 5 rule isn’t applied by default. This provision must be expressly written into the trust document. A grantor chooses whether to include this withdrawal power when the trust is drafted, and its exact terms can vary based on the trust’s goals. Without clear language authorizing it, the rule does not apply.
Trustee judgment also plays a role. Even when the provision is included, the trust may limit when and how the right can be exercised. Some trusts require beneficiaries to submit written requests, while others place conditions on when withdrawals can be made.
Because each trust is unique, the presence and practical effect of a 5 by 5 provision depend entirely on the document’s wording and the grantor’s intent.
Potential Benefits of Including the 5 by 5 Rule
Incorporating the 5 by 5 rule into a trust can offer several advantages for both the grantor and the beneficiary. By capping annual withdrawals, the rule helps preserve the trust’s long-term value while still allowing beneficiaries predictable access to funds.
This balance is especially useful when a trust is intended to support multiple generations or provide steady resources over many years.
The rule can also reduce the risk of unintended estate or gift tax consequences. Because the withdrawal right stays within limits recognized by federal law, it is less likely to be treated as a taxable lapse or as a general power of appointment. This protects the trust’s assets from being pulled into the beneficiary’s taxable estate.
Overall, the 5 by 5 rule offers a stable and tax-efficient structure that supports thoughtful, long-term estate planning.
Potential Drawbacks or Risks
While the 5 by 5 rule offers meaningful structure and tax protection, it isn’t without potential downsides. For some grantors, even a limited withdrawal right may allow beneficiaries access to more funds than intended. If a beneficiary chooses to withdraw the full amount each year, the trust could diminish faster than planned, especially if it was designed to last for future generations.
There are also tax considerations when a beneficiary chooses not to withdraw the allowable amount. When the right to withdraw lapses, it may create what the IRS considers a “lapse of a power of appointment.”
The 5 by 5 exception shields only a portion of that lapse. If the withdrawal right exceeds the 5 by 5 limit, the remaining amount can trigger estate or gift tax issues unless the trust uses specific drafting solutions to manage those excess rights.
Understanding these risks helps ensure the rule aligns with the trust’s overall purpose.
How the 5 by 5 Rule Fits Into an Estate Plan
The 5 by 5 rule is only one component of a well-designed trust, but it can play an important role in balancing access and long-term protection. Integrating this rule with the rest of an estate plan helps ensure that withdrawal rights align with the grantor’s intentions, tax strategy, and the needs of future beneficiaries.
It also works best when coordinated with other estate planning tools, such as a will, durable powers of attorney, and healthcare directives. For families with businesses, real estate, or multi-generational goals, the 5 by 5 rule can support a strategy that maintains flexibility while still safeguarding the estate’s core assets.
Explore the 5 By 5 Rule and Other Estate Planning Options Now
The 5 by 5 rule can be a useful tool for balancing beneficiary access with long-term trust protection, and it works best when its accompanying rules are clearly understood and thoughtfully applied within the trust’s broader structure. Even small details—such as how the provision operates from year to year—can influence the overall estate plan.
If you’d like help understanding how this withdrawal provision may fit into your trust or estate planning goals, our team at Bogin, Munns & Munns is here to provide guidance tailored to your needs.
We can help you with multiple estate planning needs and have offices all over Central Florida. Call our team today to get started with a consultation.
Call or Submit Our Consultation Request Form Today
